log / 2026-11-17 / 4 min
Reading a renewal notice like a spreadsheet
Three numbers to pull out of the envelope before you decide whether to stay.

A renewal notice is designed to be paid, not analysed. It shows a new total and a due date. To decide anything you need three numbers it does not print.
1. The change, as a percentage
Take the new premium, subtract the old one, divide by the old one. Renewal Check does this. A percentage lets you compare this year with last year and with what you hear from other drivers.
2. The change, per year
Six-month policies halve every number. A rise of $125 on a six-month term is $250 a year. Annualise before you judge.
3. The change, line by line
The declarations page that comes with the renewal lists a price for each coverage and each discount. Lay it beside last term's. Often one line explains most of the movement: a discount that expired, a driver who was added, a car that was re-rated.
What moves prices when you did nothing
Insurers file rate changes with state regulators as their own costs change: repair bills, medical costs, the number and size of claims in your area. A general rise of this kind hits everyone with that insurer in that state, which is exactly why other insurers may now be cheaper for you.
Then decide
- Ask your insurer what changed and whether any discount fell off.
- Check the discounts you are not getting. The Insurance Information Institute keeps a plain list: Insurance Information Institute: Nine Ways to Lower Your Auto Insurance Costs.
- If the rise is still large, compare. Your state insurance department explains how, and many publish sample rates: NAIC: State Insurance Departments.
// references
// General information, not advice about your own policy.